Foreclosure versus Bankruptcy

No Win: Comparing Foreclosure or Bankruptcy

Deciding whether foreclosure or bankruptcy is easier is choosing the lesser of two evils— neither is easy, neither is particularly wanted, and both create negative consequences.

In recent times, both have become disturbingly common. You can chalk it up to a lack of fiscal responsibility, a distressed market, or both acting in combination. Regardless, it’s a problem that many of us have to deal with.

Whether you go into foreclosure or declare bankruptcy depends of the nature of your financial crisis: are your collective debts the unbearable burden, or is it only your mortgage? Some consumers tended to overestimate the affordability of homes during the housing bubble, and now the chickens have come home to roost.

By contrast, bankruptcy tends to be the result of a long string of bad decisions, resulting from a habit of overspending and underpaying.

Yet neither bankruptcy nor foreclosure develop overnight— mortgage principals don’t magically inflate when you’re not looking, and one late credit card bill won’t bring upon Chapter 7.

In both instances, consumers take on too much risk: so much so that there is nothing to fall back on in the event of bad economic times.

High risk and little safety net create a common experience for both types of sufferers, although the details differ:

In foreclosure the only asset that can be seized is the home… but what an asset that is! Full of intrinsic and extrinsic value, losing a home is like losing an identity. It also means that you must search for another residence while trudging through foreclosure proceedings.

In most types of bankruptcies, no assets at all are seized. You can keep the house and some loans are forgiven, but there still must be a way to pay back the remaining debt: from your future income. Add to a longer period of credit recovery (10 years versus 2) and bankruptcy can be far more financially crushing.

Yet foreclosure takes a huge psychological toll by taking away the home. In the end, it comes down to whether you’re willing to suffer a bigger financial or an emotional blow.

Either way, it isn’t fun.


Note: States have widely varying limits on asset exemptions when filing bankruptcy. It is best to consult qualified legal counsel for advice concerning bankruptcy.

Alexander Carl

Alexander Carl

I find it difficult to brag about myself. Too modest? Perhaps.

Anyway: my name is Alexander Carl. I am a recent graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where I spent four blissful years earning a degree in Communication Studies. Now I face the real world of economic downturns, student loans, and the absence of “academic” camaraderie.

Yet I refuse to be bummed. My economic philosophy is to live simply, save, and maximize whatever I can. Consumer culture is undeniably pervasive, but you don’t have to sell your soul to co-exist with it— there is great power from using your economic resources wisely.

I started writing when I figured out how to hold a pencil. Since then I’ve written short stories, poetry, screenplays, and have blogged. In fact, three of my screenplays have been produced into short films, two of which I directed. I’m no stranger to the media, having served as a DJ at a freeform radio station and worked as a crew member for live TV.

Pastimes include traveling (I’ll visit virtually anywhere), swimming, jogging, hiking, and hunkering down with a good movie.

Overall I’m a peaceful person, though not in a creepy New Agey way. I get my energy from music, good conversation, and the outdoors (I was an active Boy Scout, earning my Eagle). I consider myself “inquisitive” and “wry”, and for the sake of autobiography I’ll assume that I am.
Alexander Carl

Latest posts by Alexander Carl (see all)